Mary said Yes to God. Ponderings about that yes….

God, who is infinite love, loves us.
In creating humanity, God made us to love us. And, hopefully, for us to love God in return. This reciprocity of love requires free will. Our return of love of God must be done freely; forced love is not truly love.
We first hear about humanity’s free will with Adam and Eve. God gave Adam and Eve the opportunity to live in a perpetual state of grace in which humanity would happily live in right relationship with God. Adam and Eve upended that opportunity by eating of the forbidden fruit – thus initiating humanity’s fall from grace.
Later, God the Father planned to send Jesus the son to earth in the form of a human person. This required a biological mother. Mary was asked by God – via the Angel Gabriel – to be the mother of Jesus. Again, free will. She had the option of saying yes or no to God’s request; her “Yes to God” is our highest example of submitting to what God asks of us.
Thus, a question that didn’t occur to me until recently. Prior to Mary “saying yes to God,” had another potential mother “said no” to God’s request of becoming the mother of Jesus?
This is a stunning question. A question for which we likely don’t have a historical answer. Yet, the question deepens our consideration of historical faith questions.
We would like to think God only had to ask once that a potential mother agree to be the mother of Jesus (who would say no to God?!?! Actually, how often do we not follow the prompts of the holy spirit in our more mundane circumstances?). Historically, however, we likely don’t know whether another potential mother of Jesus said no before Mary said yes. It’s possible that another woman who had all the right demographics – of humble circumstances in the same geographic region, with an intended husband who was of the Line of David, provided an immaculate conception, etc. – but who said no.
The idea that another potential mother may have said no to God’s request would seem to be theologically uncomfortable. It would be more comfortable to think that God only had to make such a request – via the Angel Gabriel – once. Yet, it’s also historically interesting to ponder whether another potential mother may have said no. It also brings us poignantly to the question of how often we say no to the promptings of the Holy Spirit. How much more often could we say yes to God? When we sense those promptings of the spirit….to be loving to another person, to “do the right thing” is a difficult situation, to be more involved in church, and…..how about saying yes to God more often….
.


